Home  5  Books  5  GBEzine  5  News  5  HelpDesk  5  Register  5  GreenBuilding.co.uk
Not signed in (Sign In)

Categories



Green Building Bible, Fourth Edition
Green Building Bible, fourth edition (both books)
These two books are the perfect starting place to help you get to grips with one of the most vitally important aspects of our society - our homes and living environment.

PLEASE NOTE: A download link for Volume 1 will be sent to you by email and Volume 2 will be sent to you by post as a book.

Buy individually or both books together. Delivery is free!


powered by Surfing Waves




Vanilla 1.0.3 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

Welcome to new Forum Visitors
Join the forum now and benefit from discussions with thousands of other green building fans and discounts on Green Building Press publications: Apply now.




    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeJan 5th 2020
     
    Hello all,
    Hoping you kind folks could answer a few of my queries regarding my proposed hot water/heating system.
    I have bought a pile of stones in a field in Sicily which once upon a time ago was a house, I have one room habitable and a second one soon to be finished. In the next few weeks I intend to install a hot water and space heating system. It is a temporary set up until I finish more of the house, so temporary meaning several years.
    Plan as follows:
    Morso Squirrel wood burner (4kw) with 8000btu back boiler in one room for space heating and to heat 300lt direct vented thermal store with combination F&E tank located in neighbouring room on gravity circuit. 1.5kw Heat leak rad in room with the TS.
    Additional solar heating to be added next year.
    Wood burner will run 24/7 in the winter.

    Questions:
    1. How/where to vent the primary circuit? Outside? Direct to the f&e tank or will the TS self vent to the f&e tank in the unlikely event of boiling? Does it require a T&P valve or tundish?
    2. I presume 8000btu is roughly 2.5kw to water is this correct? I want to be able to drive the wood burner hard often, if the TS has reached temp will the little Morso be able to get the heat leak rad hot? Would I be better off with a smaller heat leak rad and space heating the second room with rads on their own gravity circuit?

    The aim is create a simple gravity system to space heat two rooms and provide hot water.

    Also, we are off grid, only solar for power.

    Many thanks in advance.

    Kieran
      DA342AA3-1667-4FDC-9B89-FEACBE0EB28F.jpeg
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeJan 5th 2020
     
    Rotated image
      44853F32-2EAD-4F8A-9FEA-863156B98ACF.jpeg
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeJan 5th 2020
     
    The thermal store
      7014348E-C24B-4279-BABF-3F251A72512E.jpeg
  1.  
    Kieran, have a chat with Tom at Newark, and he'll explain about the pipes supplied with his unit, that link the F&E and the TS (one from top of TS to top of F&E, and one from base of F&E to base of TS). That deals with the venting side, though you need an overflow from the F&E (which could be HOT!!) and a cold feed to it.

    You'll be quite a while burning very hard to heat the 300 litres from scratch, but I guess you'll normally be taking it from say 40oC to say 80oC, which would still be 6 hours, with no other heat draw off. Sounds like you're up for that, and a fairly constant "feeding" of the stove. Remember, the rated output is often what is achieved in a lab under controlled conditions, so may not achieve a continuous 2.3kW to water.

    Without knowing anything about how you're planning to insulate the house, and hence the heat loss / space heat requirement, I'd have thought a stove that's a bit larger, say 2kW to room, 6 or 8kW to water might be more manageable, to avoid tending it all day?

    I would personally take a couple of tall/vertical gravity rads off the TS (one for each room). That means you can use the TS as intended, ie. a store of energy to be used when you want it, rather than having to run the stove to get heat into the directly linked gravity rads. I heat my 220m2 house with one such gravity rad in the hall, so I know it works. Just add 2 more connxns top and bottom (one for each rad), in say 22mm, or whatever the local standard is for roughly 1 inch.

    I'd also keep the heat leak rad to the 20% output level (or even a bit less), so that's a 400-500W rad for the Morso you've suggested. I almost feel it's unnecessary, comparing the mini output versus the relatively large mass of water, which is open, but I'm not 100% certain about uk thermosyphon regs, never mind Scilian regs (if they bother enforcing?).

    Last point, if it's not too late, do ask this forum about insulating your house, as that ought really to be the starting point, which leads to a determination of heating system sizing. Imagine being a slave to running your stove all day every day, versus a well insulated house that only needs a few hours firing each evening, not to mention a very comfortable room temperature summer and winter...insulation and thermal mass???

    Yours jealously, GP.
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeJan 6th 2020
     
    Many thanks green paddy for such a detailed response. Funnily enough Italked to mark at Newark (before I read your post) and he did explain the internal pipe work for the thermal store. I have read here somewhere that it is not advisable to use the internal expansion and fill pipe work for venting purposes, so if anybody else could chime in on this point it would be appreciated. Mark suggested that he would expect to see the primary pipe work extended and vented into the top of the f&e tank, which is how I had planned to install the vent.

    I was starting to think on the same lines as your suggestion of using separate gravity fed rads, thank you for your real life observations.
    Tell me GP, do your gravity rads have oversized tappings? Or are they standard half inch?

    In terms of insulation, it is a typical Sicilian farm house built on solid bedrock with 600mm thick random rubble walls. We are trying to use only natural traditional materials, all lime render and a coppo tiled roof. We have used 32mm thick sarking boards as insulation and will decide after this first winter wether to add sheep’s wool between the rafters internally and lathe and plaster. The coldest it gets here is 0 degrees at night and that is not the norm usually around 4-5 for a few months a year.

    Kieran
  2.  
    Rads are just standard with 15mm connections, but over sized for the output (get about half the output rated).

    The top gets nice and hot (exactly as the top temp in the TS), but the rad base is quite cool (1800mm high vert rad). Use a standard TRV to control. The fact that the water moves so slowly through it, and the exitting water is cool, is great for stratification, and also provides a really cold base for solar thermal to be chucked in, even in winter at say 40oC. Not unusual to have 75oC at top, and 35oC at the base, in the morning, after a night's rad heat draw.

    I (and I'm sure a bus load of others here), will urge you do more on the insulation front. The roof must surely be a no-brainer, if even for the summer sun (not personally familiar with that concept here in the Highlands of Scotland). You've only one chance to do insulation and air tightness.
    •  
      CommentAuthordjh
    • CommentTimeJan 6th 2020
     
    Posted By: KieranfMark suggested that he would expect to see the primary pipe work extended and vented into the top of the f&e tank, which is how I had planned to install the vent.

    The pipework can be vented into the header tank, but you still need an overflow from the header tank. In the UK the overflow needs to be taken outside to a visible spout, or else through a visible tundish inside. You can easily get an overflow if the ballcock valve in the header tank goes wrong (don't ask me how I know!) or in the worst case you might get boiling water expanding or venting into the header tank and then overflowing.

    What GP said about insulation. :)
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeJan 6th 2020
     
    Thanks GP and Djh,

    Last question about the vent pipe, after the 28mm primary flow has been ‘T’d into the top of the TS does it need to be reduced down to 22 for the last run to to f&e tank?

    Kieran
  3.  
    Not sure it would matter. There'll be no relevant back pressure diff between a 22 and 28 over that distance. Do whatever's easier. Check how the vent will pass through the lid of the F&E - question for Tom (NCC).
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Hi folks,

    I started this thread last year but for various reasons I did not get around to installing my system until now.
    Following on from Greenpaddy’s suggestion to run a tall gravity rad from the TS I have a few more questions.
    I have attached the final schematic of the TS.
    What are people’s thoughts on plumbing a tall rad (22mm pipe) to thermo siphon from the tappings marked 1 inch female heat leak at 1 o’clock on the TS drawing?
    At what point will that radiator circuit start to flow when heating up the TS from cold? In other words, as the TS is heated initially from the solar will the warmer water rise entirely to the top of the TS or simultaneously start the radiator circuit?

    Hope that makes sense.

    Grazie

    Kieran
      E5E70F89-7ED8-4BB5-9CED-751C7D96B1E9.jpeg
    •  
      CommentAuthordjh
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Make sure you have an isolating valve in the cold feed to the header tank (refer to my previous answer :)

    What's the thing that looks like a small expansion tank? i.e. what's it's purpose?
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Funny you should ask. I only unwrapped the TS last week and was wondering the same thing. It is a small accumulator tank I think but I’m not sure about the thinking behind it, I need to ask mark at Newark.
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Forgot to say...... yes the tank plumbing came fitted with said isolation valve on cold feed 😀
    • CommentAuthorEd Davies
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Posted By: KieranfI presume 8000btu is roughly 2.5kw to water is this correct?
    I realise this question is nearly a year old but some clarification might help somebody.

    The BTU [¹] is the amount of energy needed to raise a pound of water by 1 degree Fahrenheit. It's equal to about 1055 joules depending on which definition you use.

    When people talk about a boiler having an output of 8000 BTU or whatever they usually mean it has an output power of 8000 BTU per hour. Since there are 3600 seconds in an hour that's equivalent to an output power of 8000 * 1055 / 3600 joules per second ~= 2344 J/s = 2.344 kW, so yes, a tad less than 2.5 kW.

    [¹] British thermal unit, so called because it's mostly used in the US these days.
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 30th 2020
     
    Thanks Ed. All input appreciated. Although this is an old thread I delayed the install so need all the help I can get at the moment.

    Kieran
  4.  
    The expansion tank is for when you open a hot tap and run a lot of cold water through the coil to be heated, then close the tap. All the cold water left afterwards sitting in the coil will heat up and expand, but all the hot water left sitting in the pipes will cool down and contract, the expansion tank allows for this. Likewise if the TS is initially cold and then the sun heats it up, heating the water that is trapped in the coil. Our system has both an expansion tank and a pressure safety valve at this point, don't know if this is overkill.

    The thermosyphon will start when the density of the water on the 'hot' side of the circuit is less than on the 'cold' side, IE the region of the TS between the top and bottom 'heat leak' tappings has been heated to be hotter than the radiator is. When you start the stove or solar, the heated water will initially rise into the top of the TS, which is reserved for heating tap water. Only when the TS is so much heated that the region between the two 'heat leak' tappings becomes heated, will the thermosyphon start, and it will stop if/when the radiator gets as hot as that region of the TS.
    • CommentAuthorphiledge
    • CommentTimeOct 31st 2020
     
    Posted By: WillInAberdeenOur system has both an expansion tank and a pressure safety valve at this point, don't know if this is overkill.



    Its definitely not overkill and absolutely essential! If the expansion vessel loses its pressurised gas or the internal diaphragm fails, there will be nothing to absorb pressure fluctuations and eventually a pipe will rupture or a joint come apart.
    • CommentAuthorGreenPaddy
    • CommentTimeOct 31st 2020 edited
     
    A few observations, not in any particular order,and to help my understanding of your thinking, not negative criticisms;

    1. You'll want to know the TS temperature at top/mid/bottom, so I'd make use of something like these.

    https://www.amazon.co.uk/Thermometer-Temperature-External-Refrigerator-INRIGOROUS/dp/B074BSC1XD/ref=sxts_sxwds-bia-wc-p13n1_0?crid=GS0QAR7W7QTQ&cv_ct_cx=digital+thermometer&dchild=1&keywords=digital+thermometer&pd_rd_i=B074BSC1XD&pd_rd_r=64c48bb3-6a0d-4165-b62c-9f6b80e2238f&pd_rd_w=F9fXY&pd_rd_wg=WhmzC&pf_rd_p=189a32c6-b80d-4311-ae32-262249da6270&pf_rd_r=002MGF6TCQA6CVMQGPR7&psc=1&qid=1604131655&sprefix=digital%2Caps%2C189&sr=1-1-fdbae751-0fa5-4c0f-900b-865654896618

    I've never liked/trusted temp dials in all my years as an engineer. NCC can provide 10mm pockets.

    2. What's the mid point connection from the stove for?

    3. can you not take the feed to the heat leak rad directly from the stove feed pipe? I had understood from the dotted line on your sketch, that the pipe ran behind the TS, but seems like the heat leak rad is connect to the TS directly on its own port.

    4. there seem to be a lot of spare connections. I always add 2 or 3 spare ports, but just wondering what your reasoning was. You can often utilise existing connections by "T"ing into them, rather than more ports.

    5. you previously mentioned possibly adding 1 or 2 gravity rads. How are they linking in now? Maybe you could share your updated sketch of the system schematic?

    6. the temp expansion valve appears to be coming off the TS. This is open (vented?). The thing that needs protecting from over pressure (as philedge noted) is the DHW coil. Is the safety valve on that line somewhere?

    7. Consider if your stove will become a radiator when not in use, back feeding from the TS top. This almost certainly will happen. A horizontal flap check valve in the flow line will prevent this.
    •  
      CommentAuthordjh
    • CommentTimeOct 31st 2020
     
    Posted By: WillInAberdeenThe expansion tank is for when you open a hot tap and run a lot of cold water through the coil to be heated, then close the tap.

    Thanks for the explanation :bigsmile:
  5.  
    Good advice from Phil and GP.

    >>> "6. the temp expansion valve appears to be coming off the TS. This is open (vented?). The thing that needs protecting from over pressure (as philedge noted) is the DHW coil. Is the safety valve on that line somewhere?"

    Possibly that red valve is protecting the open system against overheating (boiling) ? So working in 'temperature' mode, to safely dump off overheated water before it boils, and draw cold in from the expansion tank.
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 31st 2020
     
    Many thanks for the replies and your patience.
    I will try and clarify a few things.
    Firstly, the system I have designed is largely driven by a tiny budget and the will to learn new things. My basic plumbing skills are sound, making good tidy connections in copper and plastic. My knowledge of thermal dynamics and plumbing systems is limited.
    I understand the Morso stove is far from ideal, but it’s what I have right now. I purchased the TS primarily as a future proof hot water only system but would like to try to utilise it for space heating one room (adjacent to the room with the stove. In addition to the Morso I have bought materials to construct a DIY flat plate solar thermal collector. The solar system intended is a drain back with the collector Containing a 20m 10mm copper coil.
    We get a lot of warm winter sunshine here but I have no idea how efficient my solar system will be.
    We are a family of three, 2 showers and a toddler bath a day and washing up dishes From now until April I will light the wood burner mid afternoon or run it 24 7 depending on the outside temps. I am hoping the diy solar and Morso will achieve this. The original schematic I posted utilises what I consider to be a beautifully simple and safe primary wood burning circuit. I like simple and safe. However, after a year of pondering and the inclusion of the solar I was wondering if there maybe a better way to use the TS to also space heat the bedroom?
    To answer GP’s questions:
    1. My solar controller has sensors at top and bottom of tank. I do also have a stat pocket available half way up TS.
    2. I had an extra tapping because I am concerned about the primary return height from TS to Morso and wanted the option to use a higher port if needed.
    3. Yes I can run the heat leak rad directly from the primary but was thinking that it maybe beneficial to run it directly from the TS in the hope it would get some heat into the radiator quicker. Is this logical or possibly I am mistaken.
    4.i asked for spare ports purely to keep my options open in the future as I modify and improve my systems.
    5. I only really need one rad in the bedroom and I suppose I was hoping the heat leak rad could work. I don’t really understand how the gravity rad you have suggested would work? I would really appreciate if you could explain the idea in more detail, I don’t understand how it would differ from the proposed heat leak direct from the TS.
    6. I will have to ask mark at Newark. It appears that the pressure relief valve is only for the TS unless it is plumbed to the coil internally.
    7. I had not considered this and yes I think you are spot on. Will add to shopping list.

    Any advice and suggestions much appreciated.

    Kieran
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeOct 31st 2020
     
    <blockquote><cite>Posted By: WillInAberdeen</cite>
    The thermosyphon will start when the density of the water on the 'hot' side of the circuit is less than on the 'cold' side, IE the region of the TS between the top and bottom 'heat leak' tappings has been heated to be hotter than the radiator is. When you start the stove or solar, the heated water will initially rise into the top of the TS, which is reserved for heating tap water. Only when the TS is so much heated that the region between the two 'heat leak' tappings becomes heated, will the thermosyphon start, and it will stop if/when the radiator gets as hot as that region of the TS.</blockquote>

    Thank you for this Will. :bigsmile:
    • CommentAuthorphiledge
    • CommentTimeNov 1st 2020
     
    Are you sure you actually need a a heat leak rad? Im sure you need a gravity feed to a heat sink, but this can be a radiator OR a hot water tank. As youve already got a gravity loop to the TS I dont think you need the rad unless you want a gravity powered radiator for heating. If thats the case bare in mind that the rad can get extremely hot. We have both a pumped and gravity connection to the stove but the gravity loop goes to the hot water tank, no rad, and Im pretty sure that was the config that the stove manufacturer advised.

    If you have to go for a totally gravity powered system how are you going to ensure that the TS is prioritised over the rads if the rads are connected to the primary loop from the stove? I would have thought that the rads would need to be tapped off the TS part way down so they only warm once you have heated enough DHW??
  6.  
    Posted By: philedgeIf you have to go for a totally gravity powered system how are you going to ensure that the TS is prioritised over the rads if the rads are connected to the primary loop from the stove? I would have thought that the rads would need to be tapped off the TS part way down so they only warm once you have heated enough DHW??

    If the gravity rads are on the primary loop then you prioritise the TS (or DHW) by positioning of the rad pipe work on the primary loop relative to the height of the TS. (If the rad pipe work tees off lower than the TS then the TS will have priority, half way up the TS then the rads start when the TS top half is hot).
    • CommentAuthorphiledge
    • CommentTimeNov 1st 2020
     
    Ive no experience of a split gravity loop but looking at the OPs original sketch, Im still not certain it would prioritise DHW. If the bottom of the TS was at 30 degrees and the rad was at 20 then surely the cold water from the rad would flow into the stove ahead of the cold flow from the TS. This would set up circulation through the rad ahead of the TS????
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeNov 2nd 2020
     
    Thanks Peter and Phil,
    With regards to the original schematic, my understanding is the heat link rad direct from the primary would start to flow after the primary flow had started to slow down, ie top of TS hot because of the difference in pipe size from 28mm to 22mm.

    However, I now feel the better way to go is to effectively loose the heat leak radiator and have a single direct gravity rad from the thermal store. This would allow the rad to warm up from the solar only especially in the autum and spring time. I appreciated I will probably need to upgrade and increase the size of my solar collector array first. In terms of safety, I feel the actual TS is perfectly adequate as a heat leak for the small output of the Morso and the solar Controller will turn off the solar pump (and system will drain back) when the top of the TS reaches 95 deg C.

    Any thoughts to this arrangement most welcome.

    Kieran
  7.  
    Posted By: Kieranfmy understanding is the heat link rad direct from the primary would start to flow after the primary flow had started to slow down, ie top of TS hot because of the difference in pipe size from 28mm to 22mm.

    It is not the pipe size, a small pipe will just restrict the flow across the whole system. It is the temperature of the TS that will stop the gravity flow. As the temp of the TS increases the flow will decrease. When the TS temp reaches the stove temp then flow will stop. If there is another loop lower than the TS then as the TS temp rises close to the stove temp then flow will start on the lower loop which will increase as the flow to the TS slows due to the increasing temp of the TS.

    Typically the pipe work on a gravity system would aim to keep the cross section area of the pipe work (roughly) the same across the system. so a 28mm pipe would divide in to 2 x 22mm or a 22mm and 18mm and a 22mm would divide into 2 x 15mm, of course when the pipe work goes on the return then the dia. increases as the pipes come together finishing up at the stove with flow = return.

    Gravity systems work very well but have to be designed (pipe gradient also plays an important part). The typical modern CH system usually pays no attention to gravity circulation and if the flow is too slow then the pump speed is cranked up - you can't do that with gravity !
    • CommentAuthorphiledge
    • CommentTimeNov 2nd 2020
     
    Our solar thermal is set up the opposite of how you are suggesting in that if the DHW cylinder temp gets too hot it starts to circulate through the collector in an attempt to dump heat from the cylinder. Thats a feature built in by the manufacturer which I guess would be aimed at plate collector systems as I cant see it dumping much heat through a well insulated EV manifold!
  8.  
    Kieran,

    let's try these for size...

    1. keep the heat leak, coming off the flow from the stove low down versus the TS feed, which I would connect at the top of the TS. No mid point feed to the TS. Take a radiator connection from near the top of the TS and return it at the base of the TS. That rad feed would be a gravity circuit, going to the top of a tall vertical radiator, in a room presumably not too distant, as needs to be below water level in attached F&E tank. Fit a TRV to that radiator, so you can can control its output (unlike the heat leak).

    OR

    2. Forget the heat leak. Take a vent to the roof, swan necked over. Lovely simple, safe system, that can't over pressurise. The little Morso will be bouncing and bubbling long before you get to 90oC at the TS. Fit the gravity rad as above. With stoves I always go openvented, but then I've seen the aftermath of failed relief valves, so I'd take an open line to the roof (safe place physically above the system high point) in any case.
    • CommentAuthorKieranf
    • CommentTimeNov 8th 2020
     
    Thanks Phil, Peter and GP.

    Much appreciated.

    Kieran
Add your comments

    Username Password
  • Format comments as
 
   
The Ecobuilding Buzz
Site Map    |   Home    |   View Cart    |   Pressroom   |   Business   |   Links   
Logout    

© Green Building Press